Frequently Asked Questions

Question: How can I purchase these delicious works of art?

Although Sheila Anne Pies has a permanent location opening in 2023, pies can still be purchased two different ways:

1. In person:  The Pink Lily (112 South 1st Street Jenks, OK 74037)

Need a dessert for a dinner party in a hurry?  No problem.  We have a beautiful selection of handmade pies and crusts stocked at The Pink Lily for you to take home and enjoy.

Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 11:00AM-5:30PM (closed Sunday-Monday)

2. Custom Orders can be taken by emailing at Please note that a 48 hour notice is needed to complete these orders.  All orders can be picked up at the Pink Lily during the store’s open hours.

Question: What makes these pies different?

A Sheila Anne pie is not going to be an average pie.  These pies are not only delicious, but also visually breathtaking and will make the perfect centerpiece for any gathering.  From the perfect texture of the hand cut pastry to the balance of flavor in the pie filling, Sheila Anne and her team take great pride in creating the perfect pie every time.

Question: Are there any common allergens in these pies?

Our pies are currently produced in a residential kitchen that is exempt from government licensing and inspection.  All pies are produced in a kitchen where the 8 common allergens are present: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat and soy.